Herzberg’s Two Factor Theory in IT Industry Context
Employee motivation is
crucial for organization to improve performance and meet the organizational goals,
since less motivated employees can affect the organization negatively due to
poor performance and fail to achieve organization goals (Dartey-Baah and
Amoako, 2011). Herzberg two factor theory is a motivation theory
introduce by psychologist
Fredrick Herzberg to identify the root of motivational factors and
demotivational factors of the employees (Alshmemri, Shahwan-Akl, and Maude, 2017).
Herzberg’s two factor
theory is consisting with motivational factors and hygiene factors (Dartey-Baah and
Amoako, 2011).
Figure 1: Herzberg’s Two Factor Theory
Figure 1: Herzberg’s Two Factor Theory
Source:
Marfice (2019)
1. Motivating factors
Motivation factors can be identified as causes of feel of satisfaction, which directly influence the employees to work hard (Alshmemri, Shahwan-Akl, and Maude, 2017).
Achievement
Employees should get
opportunities to perform and show the capabilities to feel achieved as per Attar and Sweis
(2010). Hence, employer essentially should challenge the employees with
different and difficult tasks which would help the workers to strive for the
work with passion and finally achieve the organizational goal (Dartey-Baah and
Amoako, 2011). Once employee completed the task successfully the feel of
happiness and proudness of oneself would motivate to do further hard work (Attar and Sweis,
2010). Tech company worker
generally gets challenging work when the clients request for new features to
support modern bleeding edge technologies as per Oluigbo and Anyiam (2014).
The pride in succeeding with a difficult set of tasks required to implement
latest technology solutions and reaching the goal is a significant motivator to
any individual working in IT industry (Attar and Sweis, 2010).
Recognition
By nature, humans are
eager to receive appreciation and recognition as explained by Attar and Sweis (2010).
Therefore, the employer should appreciate and give the due recognition to the
extraordinary efforts by the workers to keep them motivated (Dartey-Baah and
Amoako, 2011). The recognition can be pat on the back to a reward in
annual general meeting of the company (Dartey-Baah and Amoako, 2011). Most tech
companies have employee recognition with three sixty-degree nomination process, hence an employee can be recognized by subordinates, peers or supervisors,
which will be considered and rewarded with company events (Kim, 2005). The pride felt by being
appreciated creates a long-lasting impact on an individual the positive
thoughts alone motivates a tech employee to dedicate more for the organization
(Oluigbo and Anyiam, 2014).
Job status
The social status makes
an impact on any individual as described by Dartey-Baah and Amoako (2011),
hence the title of job, the prestige one feels from the occupation, is a
definite influence to stay in such employment. Employees eager to get social
recognition and employer must provide promotions according to their performance
and experience (Attar and Sweis, 2010). Otherwise employees tend to leave the
organization where they do not have the opportunity of the career growth and
prestige, especially a seek by an intelligent worker as per Oluigbo and Anyiam (2014).
Therefore, in information technology companies’ employees are assured with job
security and provided executive level titles to almost every experienced
employee making them feel proud and satisfied with their job titles (Kim, 2005).
Responsibility
The feel of being
important is another factor keeps an individual motivated, as explained by (Kim, 2005), and he further
describes employees should be given responsibilities which make them happy and
feel valuable. Accountability of the job being executed by oneself is a
definite motive for a knowledge worker to take the necessary steps to get the
assigned job satisfactorily (Oluigbo
and Anyiam, 2014). Hence, most tech companies use tools and
technologies to provide visibility and accountability to the actions of
employees, urging the workers to take initiatives to take responsibilities of
the job functionalities of oneself as per Kim (2005).
Opportunities for growth
Opportunity to growth is
vital for intelligent workforce as the ambitious nature of such individual to
reach higher career goals (Attar and Sweis, 2010). Therefore, it is essential
for the employers of tech companies to ensure the career progress for each
employee in the organization is clear and have a mechanism of fair and equal
opportunities for growth to every employee (Kim, 2005). In information technology companies to build
required skills and flexibility to change career according to employee
preferences, given that the required skills are there with the employees is
generally provided and any funding to build required skills is provided on
company expense, giving the intelligent workers ability to reach their personal
career goals (Kim, 2005).
Figure 2: Satisfiers and Dissatisfiers
Figure 2: Satisfiers and Dissatisfiers
Source:
Marfice (2019)
2. Hygiene factors
It is essential for employees to feel the hygiene conditions at the place of work to ensure the wellbeing (Dartey-Baah and Amoako, 2011). However, hygiene factors can be identified as factors for dissatisfaction if the existence of such factors not there in the workplace, which can de-motivate employees (Attar and Sweis, 2010). In tech companies the facilities for the employers are kept at very high standards in general, for example clean toilets, comfortable chairs, properly airconditioned and clean work environments, appropriate lighting are all considered significantly important (Kim, 2005).
Company policies
Company policies should
be clearly communicated to the employees and should be fair for every employee
(Kim, 2005).
The intelligent workers expect for the opportunity to communicate with
superiors and clarify if they have any doubt about policies or way oneself
might be treated due to the policies (Oluigbo and Anyiam, 2014). Therefore, the
technology is used in IT industry to keep shared and visible company policy
documentation, employee onboarding procedures to get the newcomers familiar
with company rules, regulations and policies are playing a vital role (Marfice, 2019).
Supervision
Supervision is an
essential in certain levels of employees such as interns or associates whereas
as senior experienced employees, might need less supervision and requires
freedom and empowerment to execute the duties (Alshmemri,
Shahwan-Akl, and Maude, 2017). Tech industry being relying on
innovations heavily requires the employees to feel the freedom to share their
thoughts with superiors, and get help when necessary in solving a problem (Kim, 2005). To implement the
necessary supervision of employee job functionality progress, the tooling such
as project management and planning software supporting Agile software
development methodologies are used by almost any IT firm in the current time as
per Marfice (2019).
Relationship
Relationship between
employees very important to achieve organizational goals as per Attar and Sweis (2010)
and they further describe middle level conflicts between employees resolved
in constructive ways impact organizational overall performance positively.
There should be competition between employees to achieve organizational tasks
which has a positive impact to reach organizational goals (Alshmemri, Shahwan-Akl, and Maude, 2017).
However, the culture of helping each other is equally important for building
better teams and succeeding in teamwork which is essential for tech companies (Kim, 2005). Hence, it is very
important to maintain healthy relationship between peers, superiors and
subordinates as per Kim (2005).
Therefore, tech companies focus on frequent team building events such as
gatherings, adventure events, opportunities for employees to mingle with
families of other employees using annual trips on the expense of the company,
sporting events for employees can be taken as evidence to build the required
trust and relationships between the workers (Marfice. 2019).
Work Conditions
Employee expect the
quality of work environment with good facilities which make them feel comfortable
(Dartey-Baah
and Amoako, 2011). Good work place equipment, lighting, cafeteria, clean
and pleasant working conditions are vital to make the tech employees to focus
on the job functions with a feeling of being healthy and safe (Oluigbo and Anyiam, 2014).
Therefore, in the IT companies facilities such as comfortable seating, good
computers and laptops, airconditioned comfortable environments with proper
lighting, company provided food and beverages are becoming a norm as per Kim (2005).
Salary
Monetary benefits to the
knowledge workers should be structure in a way acceptable to the knowledge,
skills, experience and responsibilities lay upon the employee (Oluigbo and Anyiam, 2014).
Essentially the employees should feel the fair remuneration package is given
considering the input the individual is giving to the company as per Kim (2005) and
she further says, otherwise unsatisfied on monetary benefits can lead for job
dissatisfaction and may cause employee retention issues. Hence, in tech
companies the compensation packages are attractive in general and on top of
direct salary package, additional monetary benefits such as family health
covers, exam fees, internet connectivity payments for the employee’s personal
data usage are provided to keep the workers motivated Kim (2005).
Status
Depending on the skillset
and the experience of the employee’s relevant job functionalities should be
assigned which suites the capabilities of an individual (Alshmemri, Shahwan-Akl, and Maude, 2017). The intelligent
workers expect the self-respect highly deserving to the knowledge one might
have gained with experience as well as academic studies as per Kim (2005). Therefore, it is vital
to create a work environment where the employees feel dignity in working for
the tech company (Oluigbo and
Anyiam, 2014). Some, IT companies highlight the employee success
and contributions in social media channels making the employee status high in
the industry making the individual proud for working for the company.
Security
Employer should be clever
enough to maintain good organizational profile and good relationship with
clients (Oluigbo and Anyiam,
2014). Otherwise loss of a client or business can make
a huge impact to employee turnover, as unsafe and insecure job tend to make the
good employees to leave (Alshmemri, Shahwan-Akl, and Maude, 2017).
Employee should feel the secure to stay with the organization even while the
organization is going through difficult situations (Kim, 2005). Hence, the assurance
given by leadership on stability of the company should be obvious to the
employees with the required level of transparency (Oluigbo and Anyiam, 2014).
The implementation of full coverage of workplace with CCTV, the car park
security provided to employee’s vehicles to be protected while employee is at
work, the company transport provided in night time due to any extra work are
some facilities implemented in many IT firms to satisfy the security aspect.
The two-factor theory
discussed in this blog shows evidence that the theory can be applicable to
information technology industry employees to keep them motivated to deliver the
duties with excellence, which would provide long term sustainability to the
tech organizations (Oluigbo and
Anyiam, 2014).
List of References
Alshmemri, M.,
Shahwan-Akl, L and Maude, P. (2017) Herzberg’s Two-Factor Theory. Life
Science Journal, 14(5), pp.12-16.
Attar,
G. A and Sweis, R. J. (2010) The Relationship Between Information Technology
Adoption and Job Satisfaction in Contracting Companies in Jordan. Journal
of Information Technology in Construction, 15(1), pp.44-63.
Dartey-Baah,
K and Amoako, G. K. (2011) Application of Frederick Herzberg’s Two-Factor
theory in assessing and understanding employee motivation at work: a Ghanaian
Perspective. European
Journal of Business and Management, 3(9), pp.1-8.
Kim, S. (2005)
Factors Affecting State Government Information Technology Employee Turnover
Intentions. The American Review of Public
Administration, 35(1), pp.137-156.
Marfice, C. (2019)
Understanding This Scientific Theory Can Teach Companies to Hire and Retain The
Best Engineers [online Available at: < https://www.7pace.com/blog/two-factor-theory-hiring-engineers>.].[Accessed
on 23rd May 2020].
Oluigbo, I and
Anyiam, K. (2014) The Role of Compensation on Employee Performance in An
Information Technology Organization. International Journal of
Research in Information Technology, 2(4), pp.548-558.
I agree with you view , According to Mullins (2006) motivation is a key ingredient in employee performance and productivity. Though people might have clear work objectives, the right skills and supportive work environment, they will not get the work done without sufficient motivation to achieve those work objectives.
ReplyDeleteAs Alshmemri, Shahwan-Akl, and Maude (2017), explain, the suitable work environment and skilled team can be built with the right policies in the organization, where the required trainings and the supportive culture would be encouraged.
DeleteAgreed with your views. Adding to that, there are number of ways to customize the company policies to align with the Herzberg’s principles which can increase the level of motivators and hygiene factors. Some of are; give more autonomy to employees, provide regular feed backs, improve workplace conditions, conduct polls/surveys by employees and focus on employee welfare (Alshmemri, Shahwan-Akl and Maude, 2017).
ReplyDeleteTrue. As per Lalitha and Priyanka (2014), the employee welfare needless to be monetary always and it could be even facilities such as transportation, medical insurance, better work conditions, which can be improving the well being of the employees where the workers would be motivated and enable retaining good employees in the organization for a long term.
DeleteAgreed with your views and according to Bawoleh et al, (2015), Herzberg's two factor theory, "Motivation factors" leads to "Job satisfaction" and "Hygiene factors" prevent dissatisfaction. Herzberg proposed six motivation factors and ten Hygiene factors and these are just created an environment for doing work. Examination of theory to understand motivation in the work environment and then actions for managers to develop motivation in the work environment and thus, an alternative approach to motivation by job improvement.
ReplyDeleteTrue. Oluigbo and Anyiam (2014) say, the hygiene factors are essential as well as motivation factors in the context of information technology industry, as the intelligent workers in tech companies, require great comfort in workplace conditions to direct their minds to think and utilize brains, to the maximum possible capacity, to provide innovative solutions to the clients.
DeleteAgree with your views. There are a number of motivational theories are in practice and each complement to one another. In addition, the Process or cognitive theory which explains the psychological processes that affect motivation. According to Guest (1992), process theory expresses a much more relevant method to motivation and can certainly be more beneficial to managers than needs theory because it provides more accurate direction on motivation techniques. The main processes are prospects, goal achievement and feelings about equity.
ReplyDeleteAgree. Additionally, Vaisey (2009), says the process theories are focused on why factor of an individual’s behavior and the actions based on why someone is doing something is a significant motivator to do such action.
DeleteTotally agreed on the points of motivators. Herzberg's points out that more salary, more job security, better company policies may provide a certain level of satisfaction to an employee, but these maintainers will not generate " a feeling of interest or enthusiasm that makes somebody want to do something." and only motivators can do that. Pophal, (2002).
ReplyDeleteAgree. The availability of better hygiene factors such as work conditions, security and good relationships enable or facilitate the successful job execution especially considering the information technology sector, however, the motivational factors are essentially influence an individual to pursue a target with passion as per Zhang et al. (2000).
DeleteTotally agree with the content Pushpa. Herzberg argued, meeting the hygiene factors of individuals would not motivate them to exert effort, but would only prevent them from being dissatisfied. Only if motivator factors were met the individuals would be motivated (Safdar et al, 2013).
ReplyDeleteThank you for your comment. Motivation is all about increasing the mental ability of the employees to work voluntary without force, hence, presence of both motivational and hygiene factors equally important (Andersson, 2017).
DeleteAgree with your points. In terms of culture, Herzberg's Two Factor Theory corresponds to an environment where power distance is small, and uncertainty avoidance is weak.In countries with large power distance, "supervision" should not be seen as a hygiene factor, because in these cultures the dependence on stronger individuals is a fundamental need which can be a significant motivator. In countries with intense uncertainty avoidance aspects related to the "policy and administration of the organization" should not be viewed merely as hygiene factors, because of the motivating potential this aspects may have in those cultures (Hofstede et. all, 2010).
ReplyDeleteAgree. Cultural influences are varying the expectations in addition to the behaviors of individuals, hence, some applicable motivational and hygiene factors may vary depending upon the cultural context, as per Matei and Abrudan (2016) .
DeleteAgree with you pushpa. job satisfaction of employee is the basic need. As mentioned by Dunnette, Campbell and Hakel (1967) and Robbins (2001), job satisfaction is an emotional state which a person perceives a variety of features of his/her work or the work environment.
DeleteAgree with your arguments. From Alshmemri, hahwan-Akl , & Maude (2017) Motivation-hygiene theory is also known as Herzberg’s two-factor theory or Herzberg’s dual-factor theory (1959). The main concept of this theory is the difference between motivation factors and hygiene factors. These two factors that have an effect on job satisfaction are divided into two sets of categories. Hygiene factors are considered less important to job satisfaction than motivation factors. Hygiene factors are related to ‘the need to avoid unpleasantness’. Motivation factors lead to job satisfaction because of ‘the need of the individual for self-growth and self-actualisation’. This theory is one of the most commonly used theories in job satisfaction research.
ReplyDeleteAgree with your idea Pushpa. It is extremely important to understand the difference between the two kinds of motivation and to accept that both types are at their most effective when both are at work (Denny, 2006).
ReplyDelete